When it comes to shaving cream, I’ve noticed that many guys assume they’re all pretty much the same. And I get it – why spend extra on something that seems like a simple part of your routine? But trust me, after trying a wide range of shaving creams, I can confidently say they’re not all created equal. The right shaving cream can make a massive difference, not only in the quality of your shave but also in how your skin feels afterward.
If you’re anything like me, you want a clean, smooth shave without irritating your skin. That’s why I’ve put together this review of some of the best shaving creams I’ve tested. I’ll walk you through why these products stand out, and how they can fit into your routine.
Before You Buy: 4 Things to Consider When Purchasing Shaving Cream
1. Skin Type
This is a big one. Shaving cream is meant to protect your skin, so knowing your skin type is key. You’ll want to consider how your skin reacts to specific ingredients and how often you shave. Some of us have oily skin, some have dry, and others have sensitive skin that’s prone to irritation. I fall into the sensitive skin category, so I’m always careful with the ingredients I use.
You might see a product labeled as “for sensitive skin,” but I’ve learned it’s not always that simple. Look at the reviews from people with your skin type. If a lot of guys with similar skin concerns swear by it, that’s a good sign.
2. Ingredients
I’ve become more conscious about what I’m putting on my skin, and if you’re the same, this is important. Shaving creams can contain ingredients like parabens or sulfates, which are harmful and can lead to irritation. Even though these chemicals are used to preserve the product or help it foam, they aren’t good for you in the long run.
When I switched to more natural products, I noticed an immediate difference in how my skin felt post-shave. Many top-tier creams now use safe, effective ingredients without sacrificing performance. If you care about the environment, you may also want to avoid palm oil and other unsustainable ingredients.
3. Scent
I didn’t used to think much about the scent of my shaving cream, but after trying a few different products, I realized how much it matters. You’ll be using this cream regularly, so the scent can make or break the experience for you. Some products have a strong fragrance, while others are subtle or fragrance-free.
Table of Contents
Personally, I prefer creams with a mild, natural scent because I don’t like anything too overpowering clashing with my cologne. If scent matters to you, make sure to pay attention to this when you’re choosing your cream.
4. Value
I’m always looking for good value in the products I buy. Shaving cream prices can range widely, from budget-friendly options to higher-end products. But here’s the thing – expensive doesn’t always mean better. I’ve found some great mid-range products that give you excellent results without breaking the bank.
For most guys, you don’t need to spend more than $15 to $20 to get a solid shave. That said, if you’re into luxury grooming, there are premium creams that offer something extra. It’s all about finding that balance between quality and price that works for you.
Here’s a breakdown of the best shaving creams I’ve personally tried, designed to help you get the smoothest, most comfortable shave possible, no matter your skin type or shaving routine.
The 9 Best Shaving Creams for Men
1. Jack Black, Beard Lube Conditioning Shave Set
Best Features:
- Packed with essential oils
- All-in-one versatility: pre-shave, shave cream, and conditioner
- Super refreshing lather
Best Shaving Cream For: Sensitive skin and anyone looking for an all-in-one shaving solution.
Overview: Jack Black’s Beard Lube set is a game changer. Unlike many three-in-one sets that are usually of poor quality, this one is the real deal. It offers everything you need for a premium shave in one neat package.
The cream’s unique formula includes phospholipids, which are full of essential fatty acids to keep your skin moisturized while supporting its natural barrier. The macadamia nut and jojoba oils create a smooth, hydrating layer that helps the razor glide effortlessly, while the peppermint, eucalyptus, and menthol give your skin a refreshing tingle.
What I love most about it is how it makes shaving easy without drying out your skin. It’s fragrance-free, alcohol-free, and vegan-friendly. Plus, the lather is transparent, letting you see exactly what you’re doing—perfect for precision shaving.
Pros:
- All-in-one formula for pre-shave, shave, and conditioning
- Transparent lather makes detailed shaving easy
- Full of nourishing essential oils
Cons:
- Not ideal for straight razor shaves
Bottom Line: This is my top pick for the best shaving cream because it combines everything you need for a smooth, irritation-free shave. If you have sensitive skin or need an all-in-one solution, this is your go-to.
2. Proraso Shaving Cream
Best Features:
- Rich, full lather
- Easy to apply
- Iconic brand
Best Shaving Cream For: A hassle-free shave, especially for beginners.
Overview: Proraso is a trusted brand that’s been around for over a century, and their signature shaving cream is a classic. It’s budget-friendly, easy to use, and perfect for those new to wet shaving.
The eucalyptus oil and menthol give it a refreshing, invigorating feel, while also helping to hydrate and soothe dry skin. It’s free from parabens and silicones, making it a safer option for your skin. The cream creates a rich, thick lather quickly and easily, making it a great choice for those looking for a no-fuss shave.
Pros:
- Refreshing menthol scent
- Affordable and great value for money
- Easy to use for any skill level
Cons:
- Contains artificial fragrance, which might irritate sensitive skin
Bottom Line: Proraso’s shaving cream is a solid all-rounder, offering great quality at an affordable price. If you want a simple, reliable shave without breaking the bank, this is the cream for you.
3. AHAVA Men’s Foam-Free Shaving Cream
Best Features:
- Foam-free formula
- Natural ingredients
- Hypoallergenic
Best Shaving Cream For: Men with easily irritated skin.
Overview: If you prefer a foam-free shave, AHAVA’s cream is a fantastic option. Its key ingredients, like lactic acid, Dead Sea water, and allantoin, help hydrate and soothe your skin while prepping your beard for a smooth shave. It’s hypoallergenic and free from harmful chemicals like parabens, making it great for sensitive skin.
However, since it doesn’t foam, you might need to use more product than with a traditional cream to get the coverage you need. That said, its quality makes it a top choice for men looking for luxury and skin protection.
Pros:
- Ideal for sensitive skin
- Hydrates and softens your skin
- Free from harmful ingredients
Cons:
- Some may miss the foam
Bottom Line: AHAVA’s foam-free cream offers a different shaving experience, but it’s incredibly effective for sensitive skin. If you want a luxurious, gentle shave, give this one a try.
4. Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Shaving Cream Bowl
Best Features:
- Rich, hydrating lather
- Comes in a classic shaving bowl
- Masculine sandalwood scent
Best Shaving Cream For: Men who enjoy a traditional shaving experience with a safety razor.
Overview: Taylor of Old Bond Street is a brand that exudes sophistication, and their Sandalwood Shaving Cream Bowl is a perfect example of their craftsmanship. The cream creates a thick, moisturizing lather that feels luxurious and works beautifully with a safety razor. Glycerin is one of the main ingredients, making it excellent for hydrating and soothing your skin.
The sandalwood scent is rich and masculine, with subtle notes of cedar and vanilla, giving you a classic yet sophisticated shaving experience.
Pros:
- Comes with a practical shaving bowl
- Creates a moisturizing, rich lather
- Bold, masculine sandalwood scent
Cons:
- Price may be a bit high for some
Bottom Line: Taylor of Old Bond Street’s Sandalwood Shaving Cream is a top-tier product for men who appreciate a traditional shaving routine. It’s worth the investment for a classy, refined shave.
5. Christian Dior Eau Sauvage Lather Shaving Cream
Best Features:
- Signature Sauvage scent
- Attractive packaging
- Glycerine-rich for hydration
Best Shaving Cream For: Men who want a luxurious shaving experience with an invigorating scent.
Overview: If you’re familiar with Dior’s iconic Sauvage fragrance, you’ll know why this shaving cream is special. It combines scents of Calabrian bergamot, jasmine, lavender, and chypre to create a captivating fragrance that makes shaving feel like an adventure.
While it smells fantastic, this cream also performs well. It’s packed with glycerine, which ensures your skin stays moisturized and smooth. There’s also cactus extract in the formula, giving it a natural touch.
Though it may not be the most revolutionary cream in terms of shaving performance, it excels at making your grooming routine more enjoyable with its signature scent. It’s the perfect cream if you love the Sauvage fragrance and want your shaving experience to complement your cologne.
Pros:
- Iconic Sauvage scent adds an extra layer to your grooming routine
- Lathers easily and provides a smooth shave
- Leaves you feeling refreshed and ready for the day
Cons:
- Contains a small amount of SLS, which may be a concern for sensitive skin types
Bottom Line: If you already love the Dior Sauvage scent and want to elevate your shaving routine with a luxurious fragrance, this shaving cream is a fantastic option.
6. Clinique for Men Cream Shave
Best Features:
- Super hydrating
- Ideal for dry skin
- Convenient for travel
Best Shaving Cream For: Men with dry or aging skin looking for a nourishing shave.
Overview: Clinique’s Cream Shave is perfect for anyone struggling with dry skin or signs of aging. Its gentle formula creates a light, puffy lather that provides a smooth and moisturizing shave.
With ingredients like Butylene Glycol, Menthol, and Glycerine, this cream focuses on hydrating your skin while you shave. It also has plenty of Vitamin E, known for its anti-aging properties, making it an excellent choice for mature skin.
The cream’s efficient formula means you only need a small amount to get a full, rich lather, which makes it a practical choice for frequent travelers. Its lightness also makes your face feel soft and refreshed after each shave.
Pros:
- Rich in moisturizing ingredients that soothe and hydrate dry skin
- Convenient packaging for travel
- Anti-aging benefits with Vitamin E
Cons:
- May slightly exacerbate oiliness in men with oily skin
Bottom Line: Clinique’s Cream Shave is an ideal product for dry skin and frequent travelers, offering hydration and protection without being too heavy or greasy.
7. Kiehl’s Ultimate Brushless Shave Cream
Best Features:
- No water needed
- Scent-free for sensitive skin
- Packed with natural ingredients
Best Shaving Cream For: Men who prefer a clean, mess-free shave with minimal effort.
Overview: Kiehl’s Ultimate Brushless Shave Cream is a fantastic option for anyone looking for a waterless, easy-to-apply shaving cream. While some may miss the foam, this cream offers a thick, rich lather that makes shaving easy and mess-free.
The formula is packed with beneficial ingredients, including olive oil, vitamins A, B, E, and K, sesame oil, and aloe vera. Together, they work to moisturize, soften, and soothe the skin. It’s ideal for men of all skin types, even those with sensitive or dry skin.
One of the standout features is that it requires no water for application, which makes it incredibly convenient, especially if you’re in a hurry or traveling.
Pros:
- Waterless application makes it super easy to use and clean
- Great for all skin types, including sensitive skin
- Full of skin-friendly, natural ingredients
Cons:
- Some may find the squeezy bottle difficult to handle
Bottom Line: If you’re looking for a simple, waterless shave that’s still luxurious, Kiehl’s Brushless Shave Cream is a fantastic option. It’s easy to use, mess-free, and perfect for men who want a quick, effective shave.
8. Anthony Shaving Cream
Best Features:
- Packed with natural ingredients
- Formulated for sensitive skin
- Free from harmful chemicals
Best Shaving Cream For: Men with sensitive skin looking for a cream that protects and soothes.
Overview: Anthony’s Shaving Cream is designed with sensitive skin in mind, offering natural ingredients that help reduce irritation and promote skin health. Eucalyptus, rosemary, squalene, and hops combine to provide anti-inflammatory, soothing, and moisturizing benefits.
Eucalyptus helps with quick wound healing and hydration, while rosemary and hops work as antioxidants to keep the skin youthful. It’s also free from parabens, so you can trust that it’s safe for your skin.
While the cream’s texture is thick, it spreads easily and creates a protective layer for your shave, minimizing nicks and cuts. It may be a bit pricey, but for men with sensitive skin, it’s worth the investment.
Pros:
- High-quality natural ingredients
- Effective for sensitive skin types
- Pleasant, subtle scent
Cons:
- On the pricier side for the amount you get
Bottom Line: Anthony Shaving Cream is a premium option for men with sensitive skin who need reliable protection during their shave. Its blend of natural ingredients makes it a gentle yet effective choice.
9. Tom Ford Shaving Cream
Best Features:
- Energizing minty scent with caffeine
- Air-whipped cream for easy application
- Luxurious packaging
Best Shaving Cream For: Men looking for a luxurious, high-end shaving experience.
Overview: Tom Ford’s Shaving Cream is the epitome of luxury. The air-whipped cream softens hair and smooths skin, allowing for a close shave without irritation. Its energizing spearmint and caffeine-infused scent helps wake you up, making it a perfect choice for early morning shaves.
The rich lather provides excellent protection against nicks, ensuring you get a smooth, close shave every time. Plus, the elegant packaging adds a touch of class to your grooming routine.
While it’s on the expensive side, Tom Ford’s shaving cream is more than just a practical product—it’s an experience.
Pros:
- Energizing scent perfect for morning shaves
- Air-whipped formula for a rich, luxurious lather
- Gorgeous, high-end packaging
Cons:
- Very expensive
Bottom Line: For men who love luxury, Tom Ford’s Shaving Cream offers an indulgent shaving experience that goes beyond function. It’s pricey but worth every penny for the quality and presentation.
How to Apply Shaving Cream Like an Expert in 7 Easy Steps
Using shaving cream may seem straightforward, but getting a great shave is an art. You can’t just slap it on and go—there’s a process that can truly elevate your shaving experience. Here’s a step-by-step guide to applying shaving cream like a pro.
1. Prepare Your Face
This first step is key. Your skin needs to be clean and your facial hair softened to get the best shave possible. Start by washing your face with warm water to open up the pores and soften your beard. If you want to take it up a notch, use a pre-shave scrub to exfoliate, followed by a pre-shave oil to help create a smoother surface for your razor.
2. Soak Your Shaving Brush
A good shaving brush makes a huge difference, and soaking it in warm water will make the bristles softer and more flexible. Some men simply run the brush under the tap, but for the best results, let it soak for a minute or two to retain more moisture.
3. Add Shaving Cream to the Brush
Squeeze about ¾ of an inch of shaving cream onto the brush. It’s enough to create a rich lather without wasting product.
4. Whip the Cream
Now, it’s time to create that luxurious lather. Swirl the brush in a circular motion in a shaving bowl (or directly on your face if you’re pressed for time), whipping the cream into a rich lather. If it looks too thick or too thin, adjust by adding a little more water or cream. You’ll get the hang of it pretty quickly.
5. Lather Up
Once you’ve got the lather, apply it evenly across your face and neck. Use the brush if you have it, or your hands if you’re in a rush. Ensure that every part of your face you plan to shave is evenly covered. The consistency of the layer is crucial; if it’s patchy, you’ll likely experience irritation or miss spots when shaving.
6. Let the Lather Settle
Be patient and give the shaving cream a couple of minutes to work its magic. Allowing it to sit softens your facial hair even more, which makes the actual shave much smoother and reduces the risk of irritation. Trust me, these extra minutes make all the difference.
7. Time to Shave!
Now, you’re ready. Shave with the grain for sensitive skin, or against the grain for a closer shave (though this can increase irritation for some). Use short strokes, and make sure to rinse your razor regularly to keep it clean.
Shaving Cream vs. Other Lathers: An Analysis
At this point, you might be wondering why shaving cream is the best choice over other types of lathers like soap or gel. Let’s break it down:
Shaving Soap
Shaving soap has been around forever—it’s the more traditional option, used since the 15th century. While soaps can offer a great, long-lasting lather, they take more time and effort to whip up compared to shaving creams. They also tend to be a bit messier, but they appeal to those who love the ritual of shaving and appreciate a product that will last a long time. Soaps are often unscented, which is a bonus if you prefer an earthy, no-fuss shave.
Shaving Gel
Gels offer even more lubrication than creams, which can help give you a super smooth shave. However, they can clog your razor and aren’t as aesthetically satisfying to use. Gel works fast, and the lather is thicker, but some men find it doesn’t provide the same pleasure that comes from using a good cream.
Ultimately, the choice between shaving cream, soap, or gel comes down to personal preference. Cream is my go-to because it strikes the perfect balance between performance and enjoyment, but if you’re in a rush or have really tough whiskers, gel might work better for you. What do you think? Let me know in the comments!
7 Useful Shaving Accessories
Your shaving experience doesn’t stop at the cream. To truly master the art of shaving, you’ll need some extra tools in your arsenal. Here are seven essential accessories to complete your grooming routine:
1. Pre-Shave Scrub
Exfoliating before shaving is a game-changer. It clears away dirt and dead skin cells, leaving your face clean and smooth, which helps prevent razor bumps and irritation. A great option is Cantu Men’s Cleansing Pre-Shave Scrub—affordable and effective.
2. Pre-Shave Oil
Pre-shave oil adds a layer of protection and helps your razor glide more smoothly. It’s like putting down a base coat before painting. The Art of Shaving’s Sandalwood Pre-Shave Oil is a solid choice, offering both performance and a fantastic scent.
3. Shaving Brush
A quality shaving brush, like the Proraso Professional Shaving Brush, helps distribute the cream evenly while lifting your beard hair, ensuring a close shave. It also turns applying cream into a much more enjoyable experience.
4. Shaving Bowl
If you’re using a brush, a shaving bowl is a natural next step. It helps you create a fuller, richer lather and keeps your shaving space cleaner. Parker’s Deluxe Stoneware Apothecary Style Shave Mug adds a classic, stylish touch to your routine.
5. Beard Scissors
Even if you’re not sporting a full beard, beard scissors can help tidy up stray hairs and make your shave smoother. A reliable option is the Suvorna Beard Scissors, which are durable and easy to handle.
6. Aftershave/Post-Shave Balm
Aftershave helps soothe and heal your skin post-shave. A quality balm like Musgo Real After Shave Balm does wonders for reducing irritation and keeping your face feeling fresh. Plus, it smells great.
7. Wash Bag
Once you’ve built your shaving kit, a good wash bag keeps everything organized. Jaald Men’s Genuine Leather Toiletry Bag is perfect for the job—stylish and practical for travel or keeping your bathroom tidy.
How We Chose These Products
Choosing the right shaving products can be overwhelming, especially with so many options on the market. We based our selections on a combination of performance, value, and overall user satisfaction. We also considered various skin types and shaving preferences to ensure there’s something here for everyone.
Each product on this list represents the best of the best in its category, and I can personally vouch for their quality. If we missed anything, let us know!
Frequently Asked Questions
What does shaving cream do? Shaving cream helps soften your facial hair and moisturize your skin, allowing your razor to glide smoothly. It creates a protective barrier between the blade and your skin, reducing irritation, cuts, and razor burn.
How long should I let shaving cream sit? Let the shaving cream sit for 2-3 minutes before shaving. This gives the cream time to soften the hair further, making for a smoother, easier shave.
How do I shave without shaving cream? If you’re in a pinch, you can use alternatives like hair conditioner, baby oil, or even soap. However, nothing beats a good shaving cream for a comfortable, close shave.
How long does shaving cream last? A typical can or tube of shaving cream lasts about 3 to 6 months, depending on how often you shave and how much product you use each time.
Who invented shaving cream? Shaving cream as we know it was invented by Frank Shields, an MIT professor, in 1919. He founded Barbasol, which is still a popular shaving brand today.
Conclusion
And there you have it—a complete guide to the best shaving creams, how to use them, and the accessories that will help you get the smoothest shave possible. What’s your favorite shaving cream? Have you tried any from our list? Let me know in the comments, and don’t forget to share this with anyone looking to up their shaving game!
