The Best Safety Razors: My Experience and Tips for Finding Your Perfect Match
If you’re anything like me, you know the value of a good shave, whether you’re rocking a specific beard style or just trying to keep things tidy. The right safety razor can truly be a game-changer. After personally testing several top options, I’ve compiled my list of the best ones out there, aimed at helping you find the perfect fit for your grooming routine.
But I’m not stopping there. I’ll also walk you through how to choose the right razor, how to use it properly, and how these stack up against other types of razors. Let’s dive in.
Before You Buy: 6 Things to Consider When Choosing a Safety Razor
There’s a lot to consider when picking a safety razor, and I want to make sure you find the best one for you. While I’m confident you’ll find a great match in the reviews below, here are some key factors to keep in mind:
1. Design
Safety razors typically come in four designs: one-piece, two-piece, three-piece, and butterfly head. Each has its unique advantages:
- Three-piece razors are probably the most popular, offering easy cleaning and blade replacement.
- Two-piece designs are favored by many wet shavers for their simplicity.
- One-piece razors (often with a twist-to-open handle) provide a quick and convenient blade change. Your choice will largely depend on your preference for maintenance and ease of use.
2. Double-Edged
All safety razors are designed to be double-edged, meaning you can shave with both sides of the blade. It’s an efficient design that allows for a close shave while minimizing the risk of cuts, thanks to the safety guard. While disposable razors may seem cheaper initially, safety razors prove to be more economical in the long run. Once you’ve made the initial investment, the only ongoing cost is replacing the blades.
3. Price
Safety razors come in a wide range of prices, from under $10 to upwards of $200. If you’re new to wet shaving or on a budget, you can still find quality options at the lower end of the spectrum. However, a higher price often reflects better craftsmanship and materials, leading to a more enjoyable and long-lasting shaving experience. Keep this in mind as you decide how much you’re willing to invest.
4. Handle Length
The handle length is an often overlooked but crucial factor when selecting a razor. In general, there are short, medium, and long handles:
Table of Contents
- Short handles are great if you have smaller hands and prefer more control.
- Long handles provide a better grip for those with larger hands but may feel awkward for some users. It’s all about finding what feels most comfortable in your hand.
5. Adjustable Blade vs. Fixed
Some safety razors feature adjustable blades, allowing you to modify the blade exposure for a more or less aggressive shave. This can be particularly useful if you have sensitive skin and want to reduce irritation. Fixed-blade razors are generally more affordable and straightforward but may not offer the same level of customization.
6. Weight
The weight of a safety razor can significantly impact your shave. Some prefer the control that comes with a heavier razor, while others find a lighter one easier to maneuver. I recommend choosing a weight that feels comfortable for you—typically around 3 ounces for a balanced experience.
The 7 Best Safety Razors
1. Merkur Futur Adjustable Safety Razor
If you’re looking for a versatile, high-quality safety razor, the Merkur Futur is a fantastic option. Merkur has been crafting adjustable razors for over 30 years, and it shows in the precision and versatility of this model.
What I love about the Futur is its six adjustable settings, allowing you to control the blade exposure. For those just starting, you can begin at a lower setting (like #1) for a gentle shave and gradually increase as you become more comfortable.
Features I Appreciate:
- The longer handle offers a great grip, especially for those with larger hands.
- The weight of the razor adds to its maneuverability, especially as you adjust to more aggressive settings.
- Made in Solingen, Germany, it showcases German craftsmanship, synonymous with quality.
While beginners might need some time to get used to it, seasoned shavers will appreciate the closeness and precision this razor provides.
Pros:
- Multiple adjustable settings for a customized shave.
- Solid, visually appealing design.
- Ideal weight for control.
Cons:
- The bulky head may be tricky to maneuver around the nose and lip area.
Bottom Line: This razor is perfect for those who want flexibility and quality. As you gain experience, you’ll find it offers one of the best shaves possible. It’s my top pick for an adjustable safety razor, and you can buy it confidently.
2. Merkur Travel Razor with 1 Blade
Merkur has earned its spot at the top of my list, and the Merkur Travel Razor is another fantastic option, especially for those who find themselves on the move. If the Futur Adjustable Safety Razor isn’t quite what you’re looking for, the Travel Razor might be a perfect fit. It features a compact, closed-comb design and offers the same exceptional craftsmanship you’d expect from Merkur.
I’ve found this razor ideal for frequent travelers who don’t want to compromise on their shaving experience. Its compact design, with a hollow handle and a small leather travel bag, makes it incredibly easy to pack. You can even fit it in your pocket—perfect for avoiding the hassle of resorting to cartridge razors while on the road.
Plus, it’s compatible with all double-edge blades, so you can use affordable, readily available options wherever you are, ensuring you won’t be left without blades, even in a new country. It’s also durable and easy to clean, making it a practical and reliable choice for those who want a high-quality shave while traveling.
Pros:
- Great for travel
- Durable design
- Compatible with all double-edge blades
Cons:
- The hollow handle may affect balance when paired with a heavy razor head
Bottom Line: The Merkur Travel Razor is an excellent option for anyone frequently on the go who still wants a quality, close shave. It’s compact, durable, and versatile—everything a traveler needs.
3. Parker 98R Ultra Heavyweight Long Handle Safety Razor
If you’re someone with larger hands or prefer a bit more heft in your razor, the Parker 98R Ultra Heavyweight Long Handle Safety Razor is a powerhouse you need to try. Weighing in at 4.3 ounces, this razor stands out as one of the heaviest on the market, and you can feel the difference as soon as you hold it.
Despite its weight, this razor maintains a perfect balance. Its genuine brass construction with nickel plating gives it a durable, quality feel. It’s built in three pieces, making it easy to clean and allowing for precise blade alignment.
Whether you prefer a heavy or light razor often comes down to personal preference. I appreciate the Parker 98R because its weight means I don’t have to apply much pressure—letting the razor do the work for me. It’s particularly effective in delivering a close, clean shave with minimal effort. However, it does take some getting used to if you’re accustomed to lighter razors.
The long, knurled handle provides an excellent grip, ensuring you maintain control, even when navigating tricky areas like under the nose. It’s a solid, well-made razor that’s built to last, and if any of its three parts wear out, you only need to replace the affected piece, not the whole razor.
Pros:
- Quality construction
- Easy to clean
- Long handle offers a solid grip
Cons:
- Some reviewers note that the finish isn’t as polished as other razors
Bottom Line: The Parker 98R is an excellent choice for those who prefer a heavier razor and want the control and balance it offers. It’s durable, effective, and backed by Parker’s long-standing reputation for quality.
4. Edwin Jagger DE89Lbl Lined Detail Chrome-Plated Double Edge Safety Razor
Edwin Jagger has built a strong reputation for quality craftsmanship in grooming products, and their DE89Lbl razor is no exception. If you have sensitive skin and need a razor that minimizes irritation, this is the perfect choice.
The DE89Lbl is well-balanced and provides a close, clean shave without the need for too much pressure, reducing the risk of nicks and irritation. The precision of the razor head is comparable to a traditional straight razor, giving you that barbershop-quality shave right at home.
The chrome finish gives it a classic, stylish appearance, and the construction is solid enough to last a lifetime. Its three-piece design allows for easy cleaning and quick blade replacements. Plus, it’s not just for sensitive skin—this razor delivers great results for all skin types.
The handle is shorter than some others, but it’s well-weighted, making it easy to maneuver. Each razor also comes with five Derby safety blades, so you’re set to start shaving right out of the box.
Pros:
- Great balance and design
- Excellent for sensitive skin
- Long-lasting durability
Cons:
- Handle may be shorter than some prefer
Bottom Line: The Edwin Jagger DE89Lbl is a top-tier razor, especially for those with sensitive skin. It’s built to last and provides an impressively smooth shave with minimal irritation.
5. Seki Edge Feather AS-DZ Double Edge Safety Razor
The Seki Edge Feather AS-DZ isn’t just a razor; it’s an investment. While it’s pricier than most other options, the quality and performance justify the cost. If you’re looking for a premium razor that’s built to last, this one is worth every penny.
The Seki Edge combines Japanese precision with top-notch craftsmanship, made from medical-grade stainless steel that’s both durable and easy to maintain. It’s designed to provide a close, comfortable shave, even for those new to using safety razors.
Seki is renowned for its Feather blades, which are among the sharpest and most efficient you’ll find. Despite the sharpness, the razor’s design ensures a gentle shave, making it suitable even for beginners.
The compact handle, just under four inches, gives excellent control and has deep grooves for a non-slip grip. The razor’s more aggressive angle requires a slight adjustment to your technique, but once you get the hang of it, the results are worth it.
Pros:
- Stainless steel design for longevity
- Gentle, irritation-free shave
- Suitable for beginners
Cons:
- Handle may be too short for some
Bottom Line: The Seki Edge is a high-quality razor that offers exceptional performance and durability. While it comes at a higher price, it’s an investment that will likely last a lifetime, making it a valuable addition to any grooming routine.
6. Muhle R41 Open Tooth Comb Double Edge Safety Razor
The Muhle R41 is known in shaving circles as “The Beast,” and for good reason. This razor is one of the most aggressive safety razors I’ve tried, and while it’s not recommended for beginners, it’s an absolute game-changer for those with some experience.
The R41 offers an incredibly close shave—many say it’s as close as you can get to a straight razor shave without actually using one. Its open tooth comb design, paired with a specially crafted blade angle, makes it ideal for experienced shavers looking for a precise, clean result.
This aggressive razor requires minimal pressure, which is great because it means fewer passes over your skin. The open comb design works to clear away stubble and residue efficiently, ensuring a smooth, consistent shave. I found that the scalloped safety bar really helped in preventing nicks and cuts, but you need to have a steady hand and patience—this isn’t the razor for rushed mornings.
Despite its beastly reputation, the Muhle R41 is surprisingly lightweight and balanced. It’s available in three versions: the traditional three-piece design, the Grande with an option for interchangeable handles, and the two-piece Twist, which is the heaviest and has the longest handle.
The craftsmanship shines through in its chrome-plated finish, showing the precision you’d expect from Muhle’s German engineering.
Pros:
- Delivers an ultra-close shave with fewer passes
- Ergonomically designed for a comfortable grip
- Available in three distinct styles
Cons:
- Not recommended for beginners; caution is needed
Bottom Line: If you’re experienced with safety razors and want an aggressive shave that gets you as close as possible, the Muhle R41 is worth the challenge. Once you master it, you’ll appreciate the results—just be prepared to take your time and learn its quirks.
7. The Chieftain Safety Razor by Vikings Blade
The Chieftain Safety Razor by Vikings Blade is a standout option for those seeking quality craftsmanship at an affordable price. Vikings Blade has been crafting razors for over 30 years, and this product shows off their expertise. Made from premium Swedish stainless steel, this razor is built to last and comes with a lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects.
One feature I particularly like is the Chieftain’s micro-comb, which makes it suitable for beginners. This design hides the blade’s edge, reducing the chances of accidental cuts and making it easier to control for newcomers to wet shaving. The advanced butterfly head allows for quick blade changes—an added convenience that I appreciate when I’m in a rush.
If you have sensitive skin or struggle with ingrown hairs, the Chieftain is an excellent choice. It’s gentle yet effective, providing a close shave without irritation. The knurled handle gives a solid grip even when wet, so you can maneuver easily without worrying about slipping.
The Chieftain’s compact head design is perfect for shaving hard-to-reach areas like under the nose. Plus, it has a satisfying weight that helps the razor glide smoothly over your skin—no need for added pressure.
Each Chieftain razor comes with a suede travel case, a mirror, and five platinum-coated blades, making it a great value. It’s also suitable for women, offering a sharper and more efficient shave than most women’s razors.
Pros:
- High-quality, durable craftsmanship
- Great for beginners and sensitive skin
- Comes with a lifetime warranty
Cons:
- Shorter handle might not be ideal for those with larger hands
Bottom Line: The Chieftain is a solid, dependable razor that’s great for anyone, from beginners to experienced shavers. It’s a versatile addition to any grooming kit, with a lifetime guarantee to back its quality.
Our Secret Formula: How We Chose the Best Safety Razors
To bring you this list of the best safety razors, I combined personal testing, thorough research, and an analysis of customer reviews. While I can’t test every razor on the market, I focus on the most reputable options and listen to what other users have experienced to provide a well-rounded perspective.
9 Simple, Illustrated Tips for Using a Safety Razor Like a Pro
Now that you’ve decided to upgrade your shaving routine with a safety razor, it’s essential to know how to use it correctly. Shaving with a safety razor isn’t the same as using a disposable; it requires patience and technique. Here’s how to get the best results:
1. Get Your Skin Ready
The first step to a great shave is preparing your skin. Wash your face thoroughly before applying a quality shaving cream or soap. I recommend shaving right after a shower when your pores are open, or you can use a hot towel to soften your beard.
2. Use Fresh Blades
Fresh blades are key to a close, comfortable shave. The sharper the blade, the fewer passes you’ll need, reducing irritation and providing a smoother result.
3. Don’t Apply Pressure
Safety razors are designed to do the work for you. Unlike disposables, you don’t need to press down—just guide the razor over your skin. Letting the weight of the razor do the work minimizes the risk of cuts.
4. Find the Right Angle
Achieving the correct shaving angle (around 30 degrees) is essential for a smooth shave. Too steep or too shallow of an angle can result in nicks and irritation. Practice finding the right position to get the most efficient shave.
5. Shave with the Grain
Always start by shaving in the direction your hair grows. This reduces the risk of ingrown hairs and irritation. It’s important to know how your facial hair grows, as it can vary in different areas.
6. Stretch the Skin
Pulling your skin tight helps the razor glide smoothly, allowing for a closer shave. Use your free hand to stretch the skin in the area you’re shaving.
7. Less is More
Avoid over-shaving by limiting each area to two or three passes. Taking shorter strokes than you would with a disposable razor helps reduce the risk of nicks.
8. Rinse Often
Keep your blade clean throughout your shave. Rinse it frequently to clear away hair and shaving cream, ensuring the razor continues to glide effortlessly.
9. Shaving Your Head
If you want to shave your head with a safety razor, be extra cautious. The skin on your scalp is more sensitive than on your face. Apply light pressure and take your time, avoiding rushed strokes.
Safety Razors vs. the Rest: My Honest Take
Having tried various types of razors, I can confidently say that each has its own place depending on your preference, lifestyle, and comfort level. Safety razors have their distinct advantages, but let’s break down the pros and cons of each option to help you determine which one is best for you.
1. Safety Razors
Safety razors are a classic choice, and they’ve become my go-to for several reasons. They offer a close shave, rivaling even that of a straight razor, without the intimidation factor. If you’re serious about achieving a smooth, irritation-free shave, safety razors are definitely worth the investment.
What I appreciate most is that safety razors give you control. You can manage the angle and pressure, which means you can customize your shave according to your skin type and facial hair. Over time, using a safety razor is also much more cost-effective. After the initial investment in a quality razor, the replacement blades are quite affordable compared to cartridge blades.
The double-edged design means you get the efficiency of using both sides of the blade, and the craftsmanship that goes into many safety razors ensures they’ll last you a lifetime. Plus, there’s something satisfying about the routine of shaving with a safety razor—it feels like you’re part of a long tradition.
2. Straight Razor
If you want the ultimate old-school experience, the straight razor is the epitome of classic wet shaving. I’ll admit, using a straight razor isn’t for the faint of heart, and it’s not something I’d recommend if you’re new to shaving. But once you get the hang of it, you’ll appreciate the unparalleled closeness it offers.
Straight razors demand time and attention. You need to strop the blade regularly to keep it sharp and practice the proper technique to avoid nicks. It’s a skill you build over time, and there’s a steep learning curve. For those who love the ritual of shaving and enjoy the precision, though, there’s no closer shave.
If you’re a purist and want to truly immerse yourself in the art of shaving, the straight razor is as good as it gets. However, it does require dedication, time, and a steady hand. It’s not as convenient or practical for everyday use, but it’s perfect for those moments when you want to indulge in a traditional, luxurious shave.
3. Cartridge Razor
Cartridge razors are probably the most familiar to most of us. They’re convenient, widely available, and easy to use. When I’m in a rush or traveling, reaching for a cartridge razor feels like a safe bet. No learning curve, no prep—just a quick, efficient shave.
However, the long-term cost of cartridge razors can be high. The replacement cartridges add up quickly, and if you’ve ever been to a store, you know why they’re often locked up—they’re pricey! Additionally, while they’re designed to minimize cuts with their fixed-angle blades, they may not provide as close a shave as a safety razor or straight razor.
Another thing to note is that while cartridge razors are convenient, they can sometimes cause skin irritation or razor burn, especially for those with sensitive skin. That said, if convenience is your priority and you don’t mind spending a bit more in the long run, cartridge razors are a solid option. They’re especially useful for those who prefer quick shaves without the need for special techniques.
4. Electric Razor
When it comes to sheer convenience, electric razors take the crown. If you want the fastest, easiest way to get a shave, they’re hard to beat. I often turn to my electric razor when I’m short on time or when I need a quick touch-up.
Electric razors are perfect for on-the-go use. There’s no need for water, shaving cream, or prep—just pick it up, switch it on, and you’re ready to shave. They come in two main types: rotary and foil. Rotary shavers are better for following the contours of your face and handling longer hairs, while foil shavers provide a quicker, quieter shave.
That said, while electric razors are extremely convenient, they often don’t provide as close a shave as a safety or straight razor. They can also irritate the skin, especially if you have sensitive skin, as there’s usually no lubrication involved. Additionally, the cost of electric razors and their maintenance (such as replacing heads) can add up over time.
Conclusion
In the end, the best razor for you depends on your priorities and comfort level. If you’re looking for a classic, close shave and don’t mind investing some time in your routine, safety razors are a fantastic choice. For a more traditional approach, the straight razor offers unmatched precision but demands practice. Cartridge razors are convenient but can be costly in the long run, while electric razors offer the fastest option for those who prioritize speed over everything else.
What’s your go-to razor? Do you have a preference or a story to share about your shaving experience? I’d love to hear from you! Let’s keep the conversation going and help each other find the best shaving tools that suit our needs and lifestyles.
