These days, a lot of guys think of aftershave as nothing more than a good-smelling cologne. But honestly, it’s so much more than that. If you’re not using aftershave to round off your shaving routine, you’re really missing out. Aftershave is like a first-aid kit for your skin, taking care of razor burns, cuts, and even ingrown hairs.
In this review, I’m going to walk you through the 7 best aftershaves I’ve come across, with the hope that you’ll find something that works for you. And hey, there’s more—I’ll also share a quick guide on how to properly apply aftershave and break down the differences between balms, lotions, splashes, and gels. Trust me, you’ll want to get this right.
Before You Buy: 4 Things to Consider When Purchasing Aftershave
I’ve learned that aftershave isn’t just about the scent, though that’s a bonus. Its main job is to take care of your skin after a shave, helping to prevent infections from cuts, soothing irritation, and keeping your face feeling fresh. So, when you’re buying aftershave, scent should be part of the equation—but not the whole story. Here’s what to consider:
1. Types of Aftershave
There are four primary types of aftershave: splash, lotion, gel, and balm. The one you choose should match your skin type:
- Normal skin: Go for a splash.
- Oily skin: Splashes, lotions, or gels work best.
- Dry skin: Opt for a balm, especially if you live in a colder climate.
- Sensitive skin: Stick to products that are alcohol-free and paraben-free to avoid irritation.
2. Key Ingredients
The two most common ingredients in aftershave are witch hazel and alcohol. Let’s break down each:
- Witch Hazel: This natural astringent tightens your pores without drying out your skin. It’s also anti-inflammatory, which is great for calming irritated skin.
- Alcohol: It’s been used for ages to disinfect cuts, but it’s harsh—it stings, and it can dry out your skin. Personally, I lean toward witch hazel-based products.
3. Other Beneficial Ingredients
Keep an eye out for these natural ingredients that can really benefit your skin:
- Tea Tree Oil: A natural antiseptic that works wonders on your pores, flushing out bacteria to prevent infection.
- Aloe Vera: We all know aloe for its soothing properties. It’s excellent for calming the skin post-shave, especially if you tend to get razor burn.
- Humectants: Ingredients like glycerol or lactic acid are great for moisturizing, helping to combat the drying effects of alcohol-based aftershaves.
4. Fragrance
Yes, scent matters. But how long the fragrance sticks around depends on several factors, like your skin type and the ingredients. Generally, aftershaves with higher alcohol content will lose their scent faster, while those with more oils will stick around longer.
Table of Contents
- Types of Fragrances: You’ll often come across floral, citrus, woody, and oriental scents in aftershaves. Keep in mind that good fragrances have top, middle, and base layers, so the scent you initially smell isn’t necessarily what lasts.
The 7 Best Aftershaves
1. Proraso Aftershave Lotion, Refreshing and Toning
Proraso Aftershave Lotion is one of those products that takes you right back to that classic barbershop experience—hot towels, a clean shave, and a refreshing splash of aftershave. Proraso has been around since 1948 and is an iconic Italian brand that still delivers excellent results today. If you’re serious about your grooming routine, this is a must-try.
What really stands out with this aftershave is its formula. It’s packed with natural ingredients like eucalyptus oil, which purifies and tones your skin, and menthol, which refreshes it. You’ll also find witch hazel in the mix, helping to reduce razor burn and irritation. The scent is mild and clean, not overpowering, and it fades after an hour or two, which I personally like because it doesn’t interfere with your cologne.
At around $14, Proraso gives you incredible value for money, especially compared to other high-end aftershaves that can easily cost three times as much. It’s also vegan-friendly, with no animal-derived ingredients, so you can feel good about what you’re putting on your skin.
Type: Lotion
Pros:
- Over 95% natural ingredients
- Refreshes and revitalizes skin
- Pleasant, non-lingering scent
Cons: - Slightly medicinal scent for some
Bottom Line: Proraso’s Aftershave Lotion is a top-notch product that refreshes and tones the skin while keeping things simple and natural. It’s a great choice if you want something reliable that won’t break the bank.
2. Anthony After Shave Balm Lotion for Men
Let’s be real: not every shave goes as planned. Sometimes you get cuts, bumps, or razor burn, and it’s during those times you need a product like Anthony After Shave Balm. Packed with natural ingredients like aloe vera, eucalyptus, and rosemary, this balm is designed to heal, hydrate, and calm your skin after a rough shave.
One thing I really appreciated about this balm is how lightweight it is. It’s not greasy, and it won’t clog your pores. It’s also packed with vitamins A, C, and E, which keep your skin healthy and help prevent aging. And because it’s so hydrating, it can even double as a moisturizer on days you don’t feel like adding another product to your routine.
The scent is subtle and minty, and while I liked it, I know some people might not find it as appealing. The only downside? It’s on the pricier side, but considering the quality, I think it’s worth it.
Type: Balm Lotion
Pros:
- Heals and hydrates irritated skin
- Suitable for all skin types, even sensitive
- Lightweight and non-greasy
Cons: - A bit expensive
Bottom Line: If you’re prone to irritation or just want something extra soothing after a shave, Anthony’s After Shave Balm is a great option. It’s gentle, effective, and leaves your skin feeling hydrated and smooth.
3. Paco Rabanne 1 Million After Shave Balm for Men
Sometimes after a shave, you just want to smell amazing. That’s where Paco Rabanne’s 1 Million After Shave Balm comes in. If you’re familiar with the cologne, you’ll recognize the scent: a luxurious mix of amber, cinnamon, blood mandarin, and peppermint. It’s bold, masculine, and perfect if you want your aftershave to double as a fragrance.
But it’s not just about the scent—this balm also helps soothe and refresh your skin after a shave. It’s great at calming any redness or irritation, leaving your skin smooth and comfortable. The downside? The price is steep, and the packaging can be a bit tricky to work with. But if you’re a fan of high-end grooming products, this one is worth checking out.
Type: Balm
Pros:
- Fantastic scent
- Soothes and relieves skin
Cons: - Expensive
- Packaging can be annoying
Bottom Line: If you’re looking for a luxurious, great-smelling aftershave that also calms your skin, Paco Rabanne’s 1 Million After Shave Balm is a premium choice.
4. L’Occitane Soothing Cade After Shave Balm
L’Occitane is known for its top-tier skincare products, and their Soothing Cade After Shave Balm is no exception. This balm is loaded with natural ingredients like shea butter, oak root, birchwood sap, and rosemary, all of which work together to hydrate, soothe, and protect your skin.
What I love most about this balm is its ability to moisturize without leaving a greasy residue. The shea butter really helps to smooth out dry skin, and the oak root cleanses and revitalizes. If you have sensitive skin, this balm is a fantastic option—it’s gentle but effective. The scent is subtle, with hints of sandalwood, which is calming without being overpowering.
The only downside is the price. L’Occitane products aren’t cheap, but you get what you pay for—premium quality and excellent results.
Type: Balm
Pros:
- Natural ingredients
- Moisturizes and protects the skin
- Calming, subtle scent
Cons: - On the expensive side
Bottom Line: If you’re looking for a soothing, natural aftershave balm that also moisturizes, L’Occitane’s Cade After Shave Balm is a fantastic option, though it does come at a premium price.
5. Barberry Coast Bay Rum Aftershave Splash
If you’re into old-school, classic scents, then Barberry Coast Bay Rum Aftershave Splash is a must-try. Every time I use it, it brings to mind sailors and adventurers from centuries ago, with its distinctive and spicy fragrance. But don’t let the nostalgia fool you—this aftershave is modern in its effectiveness.
What I love about this product is that it’s handcrafted and aged for at least 30 days before it’s ready. It’s made with all-natural ingredients, including a blend of exotic spices, citrus, essential oils, and bay leaves sourced from the West Indies. Importantly, Barberry Coast uses glycerin instead of alcohol, so you get all the hydration without the burn, which is a big win if you have sensitive skin like me.
The scent is bold and masculine, though I should mention it’s strong and might not be for everyone. Personally, I find that it mellows nicely after application. Plus, it comes with a lifetime guarantee—if you don’t like it, you can return it for a full refund, no questions asked.
Type: Splash
Pros:
- Excellent, bold scent
- All-natural ingredients
- Lifetime money-back guarantee
Cons: - Scent may be too strong for some
Bottom Line: If you’re looking for a classic, masculine aftershave with a rich history and a bold scent, Barberry Coast’s Bay Rum Aftershave Splash delivers in both fragrance and performance.
6. Billy Jealousy Shaved Ice After-Shave Balm
Billy Jealousy’s Shaved Ice After-Shave Balm is all about instant relief. From the moment I apply it, the cooling sensation kicks in, soothing razor burn and calming any irritation. It’s perfect for when you’ve had a particularly aggressive shave or used a dull blade. This balm works quickly to restore your skin’s pH and moisturizes deeply.
I really like that it doubles as a conditioner for your beard, too, making it a versatile product for those of us with facial hair. The scent is light and fresh, not overpowering, which makes it great for everyday use.
One downside is the packaging—the squeezy tube can be a bit tricky to use, and you might accidentally use more product than needed. That said, this balm is thick, so a little goes a long way. Just be careful not to over-apply, as it can feel heavy if you’re not sparing with it.
Type: Balm
Pros:
- Cooling effect that soothes razor burn
- Conditions skin and beard
- Light, fresh scent
Cons: - The tube can be difficult to use
- Can feel thick if over-applied
Bottom Line: This is an award-winning balm that cools and hydrates your skin, making it perfect for soothing razor burn and calming sensitive skin after shaving.
7. Nivea Men Original Replenishing Post Shave Balm
Nivea might be new to the U.S., but it’s been a trusted brand in Europe for over a century. Their Men Original Replenishing Post Shave Balm is a great budget-friendly option that doesn’t sacrifice quality. I’ve found it to be incredibly moisturizing, thanks to the inclusion of Vitamin E and Provitamin B5, which help regenerate and replenish the skin after shaving.
What I appreciate most is how quickly this balm absorbs into the skin, leaving it feeling soft and hydrated without any greasy residue. It’s designed to provide long-lasting moisture, and I’ve noticed that my skin stays smooth for hours after applying it. Even though it contains alcohol (which some find irritating), I didn’t experience much discomfort—just a slight tingling.
Some users mention the scent is a bit strong and reminiscent of drugstore colognes, so keep that in mind if you prefer something milder. But overall, it’s a great option if you’re looking for an affordable aftershave that performs well.
Type: Balm
Pros:
- Moisturizes and replenishes the skin
- Absorbs quickly
- Long-lasting hydration
Cons: - Scent may be too strong for some
Bottom Line: Nivea Men Original Replenishing Balm offers solid post-shave relief and hydration at a great price. While the scent might not be for everyone, it’s a reliable option for keeping your skin smooth and comfortable after shaving.
How We Chose the Best Aftershaver
Choosing the best aftershaves isn’t just about picking what smells the nicest—it’s about finding products that truly take care of your skin. I’ve tested these aftershaves based on key factors like their ingredients, how they feel on the skin, and how well they soothe and heal post-shave irritation. Each aftershave on this list offers something unique, whether it’s natural ingredients, long-lasting moisture, or a standout fragrance.
We also considered price points, so whether you’re looking for something budget-friendly or willing to splurge on a premium product, you’ll find options here that cater to your needs.
Be Kind to Your Face: How to Apply Aftershave
Applying aftershave might seem straightforward, but there’s a method to it that can help you get the best results. Here’s a simple step-by-step guide to make sure you’re getting the most out of your aftershave:
- Rinse Your Face with Cold Water: Right after shaving, rinse your face with cold water to close your pores.
- Pat Dry: Use a clean towel to gently pat your face dry. Don’t rub, as this can irritate freshly-shaven skin.
- Apply the Aftershave: Pour a small amount of aftershave (whether it’s balm, lotion, gel, or splash) into your palm. Rub your hands together to distribute it evenly.
- Massage in Circular Motions: Using upward, circular motions, massage the aftershave into the shaved areas. This helps it absorb quickly and soothes your skin.
- Let It Soak In: Allow the aftershave to fully absorb before you move on with your day. Some products may require a second application, but usually, one round is enough.
What’s the Difference: Balm, Splash, Lotion, and Gel?
Aftershave comes in various forms, and understanding the difference between them can help you find what works best for your skin type. Each type of aftershave serves a slightly different purpose, and here’s a breakdown to help guide your choice.
Aftershave Balm
Aftershave balms are hydrating lotions that are thicker in consistency compared to other types of aftershave. I’ve found balms to be a great option for days when my skin feels dry or irritated after shaving. They’re usually alcohol-free, which is perfect for avoiding that dreaded post-shave sting, and instead, they help reduce razor burns while providing a protective layer over your skin.
What I love about balms is their soothing effect, especially on days when shaving causes a bit more irritation. They’re also great for locking in moisture, which is why I recommend balms if you have dry skin. However, if you have oily or acne-prone skin, I’d say to proceed with caution—balms can sometimes be too heavy for those skin types.
Best for: Dry, irritated skin
Avoid if: You’re acne-prone, as balms are thicker and can clog pores.
Aftershave Splash
Splashes are usually alcohol-based and offer a very refreshing, bracing feeling when applied. The texture is watery, and the quick evaporation leaves your skin feeling cool but dry. If you have oily skin or if you’re prone to nicks and cuts while shaving, a splash can be a good option because of its antiseptic properties.
I typically reach for a splash on days when I want that fresh, clean feeling—especially in the warmer months. However, splashes can be too drying for those with sensitive or dry skin, so it’s important to consider your skin’s needs.
Best for: Oily or normal skin, those prone to cuts
Avoid if: You have dry or sensitive skin, as alcohol-based splashes can be irritating.
Aftershave Lotion
Lotions fall somewhere between a balm and a splash in terms of texture. They’re lightweight and dry quickly, and they often come with a stronger fragrance, which can double as a light cologne. I’ve found lotions work well when I want something that tightens my skin after shaving without being too heavy or greasy.
If you have oily skin, lotions can help control the shine while giving you a more toned, refreshed feel. Just keep in mind that if you’re sensitive to strong scents, some lotions may be a bit overpowering.
Best for: Oily or normal skin, those who want a fragrant aftershave
Avoid if: You prefer fragrance-free or mild-scented products.
Aftershave Gel
Gels are generally alcohol-free and very lightweight. They dry quickly and often have a cooling effect, making them ideal for reducing irritation or redness immediately after shaving. I love using gels during the summer when I know I’ll be sweating shortly after my shave because they don’t leave any residue behind.
The one downside to gels is that they don’t offer as much moisture as balms or lotions, so if your skin tends to be on the dry side, you might need to layer it with a moisturizer.
Best for: Hot, humid climates or those looking for a cooling effect
Avoid if: You need deep hydration after shaving, as gels are not as moisturizing.
Conclusion
Choosing the right aftershave depends on your skin type, your shaving habits, and even the climate you’re in. Balms are great for dry or irritated skin, splashes work wonders for oily or cut-prone skin, lotions provide a middle ground, and gels are perfect for quick absorption and cooling effects.
Whichever you choose, aftershave is an essential part of any grooming routine—it soothes your skin, reduces irritation, and can even give you a refreshing start to your day. As always, I’d love to hear your thoughts. Have you tried any of the aftershaves mentioned? What’s your go-to product? Let me know in the comments below!
