Pre-shave oil is one of those hidden gems in men’s grooming that I didn’t fully appreciate until I started using it myself. If you’re like me, and you’re looking for ways to improve your shaving routine, then this is something you’ll want to know about.
Pre-shave oils not only soften and lift the hair for an easier shave, but they also help protect your skin by creating a smooth layer that reduces razor friction. This means fewer nicks, cuts, and, most importantly, less irritation. Think of it as a simple addition to your routine that can save you from that dreaded razor burn.
The problem is that a lot of guys skip this step because they’re either not familiar with pre-shave oils or don’t know which one to choose. So, I took it upon myself to test out the best pre-shave oils on the market and break down everything you need to know to find the right one for your needs.
Let’s dive in.
Why Use Pre-Shave Oil?
The main reason I use pre-shave oil is that it helps create a better shaving experience. Pre-shave oils are often packed with natural ingredients like essential oils and vitamins that moisturize and soften both your skin and hair. This not only allows your razor to glide more smoothly but also helps protect sensitive skin from irritation.
If you’ve ever dealt with razor bumps or rough skin after a shave, you’ll understand the need for that extra layer of protection. Whether you’re prone to irritation or simply looking for a closer, smoother shave, pre-shave oil can make a noticeable difference.
Before You Buy: 6 Things to Consider When Choosing a Pre-Shave Oil
I know from experience that finding the best pre-shave oil can feel overwhelming, especially when you’re faced with so many options. Here are a few things I found important to keep in mind when shopping around:
Table of Contents
1. Ingredients
The key to a great pre-shave oil is its ingredients. You want something that includes oils like olive oil, grapeseed oil, or castor oil, which are known for moisturizing and softening the skin. Many oils also include Vitamin E, which is great for calming inflammation.
Natural ingredients are always best, especially if you have sensitive skin like I do. It’s important to avoid anything that might irritate your skin or clog your pores.
2. Skin Type
Take your skin type into account. If your skin is sensitive or prone to breakouts, go for a lighter oil that won’t clog your pores. If you have coarse facial hair, opt for a thicker oil that will better penetrate your skin and soften your beard before shaving.
3. Container Type
It might seem like a minor detail, but the type of container can make a big difference in how easy it is to apply the oil. I personally like droppers or pumps because they let me control how much oil I’m using without wasting any. Plus, bottles made from amber glass help keep the oil fresh by blocking out sunlight.
4. Price
Pre-shave oils come in a wide range of prices, but don’t assume that higher-priced oils are automatically better. Some of the more affordable oils can be just as effective as premium ones, so I recommend finding a balance between quality ingredients and price.
5. Quantity
Even though most pre-shave oils come in small bottles, you’ll be surprised by how little you need per shave. A couple of drops go a long way, so don’t worry if the bottle looks small. It will last longer than you think.
6. Scent
The scent might not be a dealbreaker for everyone, but it’s worth considering. Some oils have strong fragrances, while others are unscented. Personally, I prefer something subtle so it doesn’t clash with my aftershave, but this is a personal choice.
The 7 Best Pre-Shave Oils
I’ve spent some time testing these oils, and here’s my take on the ones that stood out the most:
1. The Art of Shaving Pre-Shave Oil, Sandalwood
I’ve got to say, the Art of Shaving Pre-Shave Oil lives up to its reputation. It’s thick and provides an excellent protective layer, which means your razor glides smoothly without causing irritation. The blend of castor oil, olive oil, and chamomile extract makes it both effective and gentle.
The sandalwood scent is subtle, and I appreciated that it didn’t overpower my aftershave. A little goes a long way with this oil, so even though it’s on the pricier side, a small bottle will last you a while.
Pros:
- Great blend of natural oils
- Thick texture provides excellent protection
- Subtle sandalwood scent
Cons:
- The dispenser can be a bit tricky
Bottom Line: If you’re looking for a high-quality pre-shave oil that delivers a smooth shave with minimal irritation, this is one of the best options out there.
2. Alonzo’s Sensational Shave
If you use a straight razor, you’ll love Alonzo’s Sensational Shave Oil. It’s incredibly smooth and provides clear visibility, which is ideal when precision matters. Plus, it’s made from six all-natural ingredients like grapeseed, olive, and avocado oils, so it’s good for your skin too.
I was impressed with how soft my skin felt after using this oil, and the fact that it’s completely natural is a big win. It even comes with a 100-day money-back guarantee, so you’ve got nothing to lose by trying it.
Pros:
- Perfect for straight razors
- Completely natural ingredients
- Leaves skin feeling soft
Cons:
- The bottle can be tricky to use at first
Bottom Line: A versatile, all-natural pre-shave oil that’s perfect for straight razor users and anyone looking to soften their skin.
3. Maison Lambert Pre Shave Oil
If you’ve got sensitive skin like I do, shaving can sometimes feel like more of a battle than it needs to be. That’s why Maison Lambert Pre Shave Oil really caught my attention. It’s specifically designed for guys with sensitive skin, and it’s completely organic, which I love because it means fewer chemicals messing with my skin.
This oil is fragrance-free, which is another plus if you’re like me and prefer unscented grooming products. The ingredients are all-natural, including jojoba oil, grapeseed oil, and castor oil. These not only help to moisturize your skin but also promote healthier and faster-growing facial hair. And I’ve noticed it gives my skin a protective layer, making it easier for my shaving cream to stay balanced throughout the shave.
It’s a little pricier than some other options, but if you’ve got sensitive skin and are looking for something organic that really works, you’ll see why it’s worth it.
Pros:
- Excellent for sensitive skin
- Completely organic and fragrance-free
Cons:
- The bottle size is a bit small for the price
Bottom Line: If you struggle with sensitive skin and want a pre-shave oil that’s 100% organic, Maison Lambert is a great choice. It’s gentle, protective, and does its job without irritating your skin.
4. Pacific Shaving Company Natural Shave Oil
I’ve been there—dealing with razor burn and cuts after a shave, especially with sensitive skin. That’s why I really appreciate the Pacific Shaving Company’s Natural Shave Oil. This oil is specifically made with sensitive-skinned guys in mind, and it’s loaded with natural ingredients like sunflower seed oil, avocado oil, and aloe vera that soothe the skin and reduce irritation.
What I liked most about it is the texture—it’s thick enough to provide a good protective layer but not so thick that it feels sticky or heavy. It lets the blade glide smoothly without feeling like you’ve slathered on too much product. And even though it’s all-natural, it still gives you that slick feel that makes for an easy, irritation-free shave.
One thing to keep in mind is that it’s a smaller bottle, but you only need a few drops each time, so it lasts longer than you’d expect.
Pros:
- Ideal for sensitive skin
- Great slickness and protection
- Made with all-natural ingredients
Cons:
- A bit pricey for the size
Bottom Line: If you have sensitive skin and want an all-natural pre-shave oil that provides great protection, Pacific Shaving Company’s Natural Shave Oil is a solid pick. It keeps your skin moisturized and protected, so you can shave without worrying about irritation.
5. Lather & Wood Shaving Unscented Pre-Shave Oil
If you’re someone who deals with tough whiskers or gets razor burn easily, Lather & Wood’s Unscented Pre-Shave Oil might be exactly what you need. I tried this out on days when my skin felt extra sensitive, and I was impressed by how well it worked. This oil is made with seven natural oils like grapeseed, olive oil, and cranberry oil, which really help soften your facial hair and make shaving a breeze.
One pump of the bottle, and 30 seconds later, your skin and beard are ready for the razor. The pump design is a nice touch, too, because it ensures you’re not wasting any oil, which can sometimes happen with other bottles.
Another thing I liked is how slick it made my skin. Even on days when I was in a rush, I didn’t have to worry about my blade pulling or catching, and that’s a game-changer if you’ve ever had to deal with rushed shaves.
Pros:
- Perfect for tough whiskers and sensitive skin
- Only need a small amount for each shave
- Made with all-natural oils
Cons:
- Some users wish the bottle was a bit larger
Bottom Line: Lather & Wood’s Unscented Pre-Shave Oil is a great option if you’re prone to razor burn or have thicker facial hair. It gives you the protection you need for a smooth, comfortable shave.
6. Taylor of Old Bond Street Pre-Shave Oil
If you’re a fan of anything with a classic, vintage vibe, Taylor of Old Bond Street Pre-Shave Oil might just be up your alley. The packaging gives off that old-school barber shop feel, and the product itself lives up to the brand’s reputation for quality.
This oil has a thick consistency, so you don’t need much to cover your face. I found it provided a solid barrier that allowed my razor to glide smoothly without any irritation. And even though it’s on the thicker side, it doesn’t clog up your razor, which is a huge plus.
One thing to note is the sandalwood scent—it’s strong, so if you’re not a fan of bold fragrances, it might not be your favorite. But the scent fades quickly, so it wasn’t a dealbreaker for me.
Pros:
- Helps create a smooth, close shave
- Rich in texture, so a little goes a long way
- Vintage packaging
Cons:
- Some might find the sandalwood scent overpowering
Bottom Line: Taylor of Old Bond Street Pre-Shave Oil is perfect if you like your grooming routine to have a classic feel. It’s thick, protective, and gives you a smooth shave, just like the old-school barbershops.
7. Shave Secret Shaving Oil
If you’re looking for a budget-friendly option that still delivers excellent results, Shave Secret Shaving Oil is a great pick. I was skeptical at first because of the low price, but after trying it out, I can honestly say it holds its own against pricier oils.
One of the best things about it is that you only need a couple of drops to get the job done, so even though the bottle is small, it lasts for a good amount of time. It’s also got a unique blend of essential oils that provides solid lubrication, and it works well with any type of razor.
And here’s the bonus—women love it too, especially for shaving around sensitive areas like the bikini line. So, it’s a versatile option for anyone in the household.
Pros:
- Great value for the price
- Provides excellent lubrication
- A little goes a long way
Cons:
- Some users say it clogs the razor
Bottom Line: Shave Secret Shaving Oil is a fantastic budget option that performs just as well as more expensive brands. If you’re new to pre-shave oils or just want to save some money, this is definitely one to try.
Choosing the best pre-shave oils
When it came to picking out the best pre-shave oils, I focused on what really matters: performance. If an oil caused nicks, cuts, or irritated my skin, it didn’t make the cut. We’re looking for smooth, irritation-free shaves here, after all! I also paid close attention to the ingredients—natural ingredients always win in my book. I considered price and how much product you get for your money, too. Scent isn’t my top priority, but it’s always worth considering, especially if you like or dislike certain fragrances.
How to apply pre-shave oil (A simple guide)
Applying pre-shave oil isn’t rocket science, but like with any grooming product, there’s a right way to do it. Here’s how I’ve found it works best for me:
1. Heat up your skin and whiskers
Start by opening up your pores and softening those whiskers. A hot shower or even a hot towel on your face works wonders. This step makes your facial hair easier to shave and less likely to cause irritation. Once you’re done, gently pat your face dry. Don’t rub it—you don’t want to irritate your skin before you even start.
2. Apply the oil
Now, it’s time for the oil. You don’t need a lot; three to five drops (about a dime-sized amount) is usually perfect. Rub it between your hands and gently massage it into your skin. The oil will soften your beard, protect your skin, and add an extra layer of moisture—everything you need for a smooth shave.
3. Apply your shave cream
Next up is your shaving cream. If you’re like me and prefer wet shaving, you’ll want to use a shaving brush. Not only does it help spread the cream evenly, but it also lifts your hair follicles, giving you a closer shave. Trust me, it makes a big difference compared to applying the cream with your fingers.
4. Shave
Now you’re ready to shave. I won’t get into shaving techniques here, but make sure you’ve got a good razor—especially if you have sensitive skin. The combination of pre-shave oil and a high-quality razor will give you the closest, smoothest shave with minimal irritation.
Pre-shave oil vs. all the rest
You might be wondering how pre-shave oil stacks up against other grooming products, so let’s break it down. First off, pre-shave oil is not the same as beard oil. While both are used on facial hair, their purposes are different. Beard oil is designed to soften and hydrate your beard, while pre-shave oil preps your skin and facial hair for a smooth, irritation-free shave.
Pre-shave oil lifts your whiskers away from your skin and creates a protective layer between your skin and the razor. This makes it much easier to get a close shave without nicks, cuts, or irritation. If you regularly struggle with razor burn or skin irritation, adding a pre-shave oil to your routine is a game-changer.
Pre-shave oils typically include a mix of essential oils, carrier oils, and vitamins, with carrier oils making up the majority of the solution. Oils like castor, grapeseed, and argan are commonly used in these blends. Castor oil, in particular, is known for its ability to soothe and hydrate the skin while helping to reduce inflammation.
While some guys use pre-shave oil on its own, I recommend layering it with shaving cream or gel for the best results. The oil creates a slick base that makes the cream glide smoothly, giving you the ultimate shave.
Shaving Soap
Shaving soap is as old-school as it gets. It’s been around for centuries, and for good reason—it works. Unlike pre-shave oil or shave cream, shaving soap comes in a solid, puck-like form. You’ll need to take a bit more time to build a lather by adding water, but trust me, the lubrication it provides is second to none.
Triple-milled shaving soaps are the cream of the crop. They’re more expensive, but they last forever and give you a super dense, rich lather. Most shaving soaps have a subtle scent, like sandalwood, but you won’t find anything overpowering.
Shaving Foam
Shaving foam is probably what most guys think of when they picture shaving cream. It’s the stuff that comes in an aerosol can and is found on every drugstore shelf. Shaving foam contains a lot of air, which gives it that fluffy texture. While it’s easy to apply, the extra air can make it harder for your whiskers to stand upright, increasing the chance of razor burn.
That being said, many shaving foams include ingredients like aloe vera to help the razor glide smoothly across your skin, reducing irritation. It’s a great product for beginners since you don’t have to worry about building the lather yourself.
Shave Cream
Shave cream is a fantastic alternative to both shaving foam and gel. It usually comes in a tube and gives you a rich lather with just a small amount. Shaving creams contain ingredients that soften your beard and protect your skin, keeping it moisturized long after you’ve finished shaving. It’s particularly good for guys with sensitive skin or those prone to irritation.
Shave Gel
Shave gel is a latherless option that’s perfect for men with sensitive skin. Most shave gels are fragrance-free and provide excellent lubrication without drying out your skin. One of the best things about gels is that they’re transparent, so you can see exactly where you’re shaving. If you’ve got sensitive or dry skin, shave gel is definitely worth a try.
Conclusion
Whether you’re a pre-shave oil enthusiast or just getting started, the right product can make all the difference in your shaving experience. I’ve shared my favorites, but I’d love to hear from you. What pre-shave oils have you tried? Have you had success with any from this list? Drop a comment below—I’m always up for learning about new products and hearing about your experiences.
Until next time, happy shaving!
